The Meccan opposition had a problem. They could not attack the message — it was too coherent, too beautiful, too internally consistent. So they attacked the messenger. And the charges they brought reveal more about the accusers than the accused.
Charge One: The Quran is fabricated. "This is nothing but a lie that he made up, and others have helped him at it" 25:4. The allegation is conspiracy — that Muhammad colluded with unnamed accomplices to forge a text and pass it off as divine. God's verdict is blunt: "They have committed an injustice and a perjury." The counter-evidence? "It was revealed by He who knows the Secret in the heavens and the earth" 25:6. The prosecution's challenge is simple: the Quran contains knowledge no human conspiracy could produce. Disprove that, or withdraw the charge.
Charge Two: The Quran is recycled mythology. "Tales of the ancients; he wrote them down; they are dictated to him morning and evening" 25:5. Muhammad, an illiterate man in a largely illiterate society, is accused of running a scribal operation. The absurdity is its own rebuttal, but the Quran does not rely on irony. It relies on content: the stories it tells carry moral and spiritual architecture that no mere retelling could replicate.
Charge Three: The messenger is too ordinary. This is the most revealing objection of all. "What sort of messenger is this, who eats food, and walks in the marketplaces?" 25:7. They wanted a supernatural being — an angel, a treasure-bearer, a man with a private garden and visible divine patronage. God's response is devastating in its simplicity: "We never sent any messengers before you, but they ate food and walked in the marketplaces" 25:20. Every prophet in history was human. That is the design, not the defect. The Meccans wanted a god-man. God sent a man — deliberately, specifically, as a test.
Charge Four: If this were real, angels would accompany him. "If only an angel was sent down with him, to be alongside him a warner" 25:7. The Quran's answer is chilling: "On the Day when they see the angels — there will be no good news for sinners on that Day" 25:22. You will see angels. The day you do will be the day you can no longer benefit from the warning they would have brought.
The prosecution rests. Every charge has been answered. Every objection has been turned back on the objector. The Meccans asked for signs. God pointed them to the shadow that moves across the ground, the night that covers them in sleep, the wind that carries rain to dead land, the barrier between fresh and salt water. The signs were everywhere. They were looking at the wrong things.