Edition 58 of 114 Medina Bureau 22 Verses

The Daily Revelation

Revelation. Reported. Truth.
المجادلة

Al-Mujadila — The Pleading Woman
Force: Strong Tone: Compassionate with embedded warning Urgency: Urgent

THE PLEADING WOMAN: When One Wife's Protest Reached the Throne of God and Rewrote the Law

She had no court, no lawyer, no tribunal. Her husband had declared her 'like his mother's back' -- a single sentence that, under pre-Islamic custom, froze her in permanent legal limbo. So she did the only thing left: she argued her case directly to God. And God answered.


A solitary woman standing in the courtyard of an ancient Medinan dwelling at dawn, her face lifted upward in passionate supplication, with light breaking through the palm-thatched roof above her
58:1 -- God has heard the statement of she who argued with you concerning her husband

In the entire Quran -- 6,236 verses spanning twenty-three years of revelation -- there are very few moments where God announces that He has heard a specific individual's complaint and is responding in real time. Al-Mujadila opens with one of those moments. A woman, identified by the scholars as Khawlah bint Tha'labah, has come to the Prophet Muhammad, peace be upon him, to protest her husband's use of zihar -- an old Arabian custom in which a man declares his wife to be 'like his mother's back,' a phrase that effectively made her neither wife nor divorcee, trapped in a marriage she could not consummate and a divorce she was never granted. The Prophet has no immediate answer. But God does. The first verse of this surah does not begin with a command or a theological principle. It begins with a statement of fact: 'God has heard.' Not 'God will hear.' Not 'God may consider.' He has already heard. The past tense is deliberate. Before the revelation is even complete, the verdict is already in. And what follows is not merely a ruling on one woman's marriage. It is a systematic dismantling of a pre-Islamic custom, a graduated system of expiation that turns a moment of marital cruelty into an engine of social justice -- freeing slaves, feeding the poor, demanding accountability. One woman's protest did not merely reach God. It changed the law for every generation that followed.

“God has heard the statement of she who argued with you concerning her husband, as she complained to God. God heard your conversation. God is Hearing and Seeing.”
— Allah 58:1
Spiritual Barometer
Force
strong
Tone
compassionate with embedded warning
Urgency
urgent

The Daily Revelation Edition 58

Lead Story

GOD HAS HEARD: How One Woman's Marital Complaint Became Revelation and Abolished a Custom That Had Trapped Wives for Centuries

The Arabic word mujadila means 'the woman who argues,' 'the woman who disputes,' 'the woman who pleads.' Every English translation grasps at a different facet of the same act: a woman who will not be silent. The surah named after her opens not with her argument but with God's response to it: "God has heard the statement of she who argued with you concerning her husband, as she complained to God. God heard your conversation. God is Hearing and Seeing" 58:1. Note the architecture. God has heard -- past tense, completed action. She complained to God -- present continuous, an ongoing act. God heard your conversation -- a third repetition of hearing, this time specifying that the exchange between the woman and the Prophet was not merely overheard but witnessed. And then the divine signature: Hearing and Seeing. Two attributes. Four declarations of divine awareness in a single verse. No complaint from the oppressed is lost.

The practice she was protesting -- zihar -- was one of the most psychologically cruel customs in pre-Islamic Arabia. A husband who wished to punish his wife but did not want to formally divorce her (which would require returning her dowry and freeing her to remarry) could simply declare: 'You are to me as my mother's back.' This single sentence created a legal and sexual paralysis. The wife was not divorced -- she could not leave, could not remarry, could not seek another household. But she was also not a wife -- the husband would not touch her, would not fulfil his marital obligations, would treat her as though she did not exist as a woman. She became a ghost in her own home. Zihar was not divorce. It was erasure.

The Quran's response is immediate, categorical, and devastating in its simplicity: "Those of you who estrange their wives by equating them with their mothers--they are not their mothers. Their mothers are none else but those who gave birth to them. What they say is evil, and a blatant lie. But God is Pardoning and Forgiving" 58:2. The ruling operates on multiple levels simultaneously. First, it is a statement of biological fact: your wife is not your mother. The comparison is anatomically, legally, and morally absurd. Second, it is a moral judgment: what these men say is munkar (evil, objectionable) and zur (a lie, a falsehood). The Quran does not merely prohibit zihar. It names it as what it is -- a lie. Third, and remarkably, it offers mercy even in condemnation: God is Pardoning and Forgiving. The door of repentance is not closed. The custom is abolished, but the men who practised it are not beyond redemption.

What follows is one of the most precisely graduated systems of expiation in the entire Quran. The husband who has committed zihar and wishes to return to his wife must first free a slave: "Those who estrange their wives by equating them with their mothers, then go back on what they said, must set free a slave before they may touch one another. To this you are exhorted, and God is well aware of what you do" 58:3. If he cannot afford a slave, he must fast for two consecutive months. If he cannot fast, he must feed sixty needy people: "But whoever cannot find the means must fast for two consecutive months before they may touch one another. And if he is unable, then the feeding of sixty needy people. This, in order that you affirm your faith in God and His Messenger. These are the ordinances of God. The unbelievers will have a painful punishment" 58:4. The graduated structure -- from manumission to fasting to charity -- is not arbitrary. Each tier serves a different psychological and social function. Freeing a slave is the most dramatic act: it transforms a moment of domestic cruelty into an act of liberation for another human being. Fasting is internal discipline: sixty consecutive days of self-denial to counterbalance the self-indulgence of zihar. Feeding the poor is communal repair: the damage done to one relationship must be compensated by service to the wider society. The private sin must produce public good.

The scholars have long noted that the woman behind this revelation -- traditionally identified as Khawlah bint Tha'labah -- did something extraordinary. She did not accept the Prophet's initial silence as a final answer. She persisted. She argued. She complained to God Himself. And God vindicated her. Aisha, the Prophet's wife, is reported to have said: 'Blessed is she whose hearing encompasses all things. I was in the same room as the Messenger of God, and I could not hear all of her words -- but God heard her from above the seven heavens.' The woman who could barely be heard across a room was heard across the entire cosmos.

58:1 58:2 58:3 58:4

The Daily Revelation Edition 58

Investigation

THE GOD WHO COUNTS TO SIX: Divine Omniscience and the Psychology of Secret Conspiracies

There is a verse in the middle of Al-Mujadila that, once read carefully, makes it impossible to think about privacy the same way again. It is verse seven, and it operates like a surveillance camera that has always been on: "Do you not realize that God knows everything in the heavens and everything on earth? There is no secret counsel between three, but He is their fourth; nor between five, but He is their sixth; nor less than that, nor more, but He is with them wherever they may be. Then, on the Day of Resurrection, He will inform them of what they did. God has knowledge of everything" 58:7.

The specificity is what arrests you. God does not say 'I know everything' -- though He does. He counts. Three becomes four. Five becomes six. He inserts Himself into the arithmetic of human conspiracy with a precision that is both comforting and terrifying, depending on which side of the moral ledger you stand. The verse does not distinguish between innocent conversation and sinful plotting. It states a universal fact: whenever human beings gather to speak privately, God is already there. He is not listening from a distance. He is present. The fourth. The sixth. The plus-one who was never invited but never needed to be.

The historical context intensifies the verse's force. In Medina, the early Muslim community was navigating a landscape thick with conspiracy. Hypocrites within the community were holding secret meetings to coordinate opposition to the Prophet. Certain factions in Medina were conspiring with external enemies against the Muslims. The atmosphere was one of whispered alliances and coded signals. Into this environment, the Quran drops a single verse that renders all secrecy pointless. You can close the door, lower your voice, choose your allies carefully -- but the room already has one more occupant than you counted.

The verses that follow trace the psychology of these conspirators with clinical precision. They were forbidden from whispering together, yet they returned to it: "Have you noted those who were prohibited from conspiring secretly, but then reverted to what they were prohibited from? They conspire to commit sin, and aggression, and defiance of the Messenger. And when they come to you, they greet you with a greeting that God never greeted you with. And they say within themselves, "Why does God not punish us for what we say?" Hell is enough for them. They will roast in it. What a miserable destiny!" 58:8. This is addiction psychology expressed in seventh-century Arabic. They were told to stop. They stopped. Then they started again. The compulsion to conspire -- to feel the thrill of shared secrets, the power of hidden knowledge, the intoxication of defiance -- overrode the prohibition.

The Quran's prescription for the believers is starkly different: "O you who believe! When you converse secretly, do not converse in sin, and aggression, and disobedience of the Messenger; but converse in virtue and piety; And fear God, to Whom you will be gathered" 58:9. The prohibition is not against private conversation itself but against its weaponisation. Privacy is permitted. Conspiracy is not. The line between the two is drawn by content, not by form.

And the Quran diagnoses the root cause with a single verse: "Conspiracies are from Satan, that he may dishearten those who believe; but he will not harm them in the least, except by leave of God. So let the believers put their trust in God" 58:10. Satan does not conspire. He inspires conspiracy. The whisperers think they are acting on their own initiative, pursuing their own interests, executing their own plans. But the energy that drives them -- the paranoia, the tribalism, the need to undermine -- is Satanic in origin. And its purpose is not to destroy the believers physically but to dishearten them. The Arabic li-yahzuna means to cause grief, sadness, psychological distress. Satan's weapon is not fire. It is mood. He wants the believers to feel outnumbered, outmanoeuvred, alone. And the Quran's antidote is not counter-intelligence but tawakkul -- radical trust in the One who is already the fourth in every room of three.

58:7 58:8 58:9 58:10

The Daily Revelation Edition 58

Social Commentary

MAKE ROOM: The Forgotten Verse That Turned Gathering Etiquette Into Spiritual Law

Buried in the middle of a surah about zihar, conspiracy, and cosmic allegiance is a verse about seating arrangements. It is easy to pass over. It should not be: "O you who believe! When you are told to make room in your gatherings, make room; God will make room for you. And when you are told to disperse, disperse. God elevates those among you who believe, and those given knowledge, many steps. God is Aware of what you do" 58:11.

On the surface, this is a verse about etiquette. When someone arrives at a gathering and there is no space, the seated must shift. When the gathering ends, people should leave. Simple. But the Quran does not legislate trivialities. The fact that seating etiquette receives a verse in a surah about divine omniscience and the fate of the hypocrites tells us that something far deeper is being addressed.

The scholars have identified multiple layers. First, the practical: in the Prophet's mosque in Medina, space was limited. Senior companions would arrive early and claim positions near the Prophet. Latecomers -- sometimes newer Muslims, sometimes the poor -- would find no room and be forced to stand at the margins. The verse intervenes: move. Make space. Your proximity to the Prophet is not a property right. It is a temporary privilege that must be shared. Second, the psychological: the refusal to make room for another is, at its root, an act of ego. It says: my comfort matters more than your inclusion. My position matters more than your presence. The Quran collapses this hierarchy with a single conditional: if you make room for others, God will make room for you. The reciprocity is divine. Your generosity in a crowded mosque will be repaid by God's generosity in an infinitely larger arena.

And then the verse pivots to its most consequential claim: "God elevates those among you who believe, and those given knowledge, many steps." This is one of the Quran's clearest statements on the hierarchy of human worth. Not wealth. Not lineage. Not military prowess. Not political connection. Belief and knowledge. Iman and ilm. These are the only two currencies that purchase elevation in God's economy. A man who moves aside to make room for a scholar has done more for his own rank than a man who builds a palace.

The verse that follows extends this logic into the Prophet's private consultations: "O you who believe! When you converse privately with the Messenger, offer something in charity before your conversation. That is better for you, and purer. But if you do not find the means--God is Forgiving and Merciful" 58:12. Access to the Prophet's time was not free. Or rather, it was free -- but it should cost something. The instruction to give charity before a private meeting served a dual purpose: it filtered out those who sought the Prophet's attention for frivolous reasons, and it ensured that every private consultation generated a public benefit. Your question might help only you. But the charity you gave to ask it has already helped someone else.

The scholars note that this requirement was later eased: "Are you reluctant to offer charity before your conversation? If you do not do so, and God pardons you, then perform the prayer, and give alms, and obey God and His Messenger. God is Aware of what you do" 58:13. Ali ibn Abi Talib is reported to have been the only companion who actually fulfilled the original command before it was relaxed. But the principle it established endures: proximity to sacred knowledge carries a cost, and that cost should benefit the community.

58:5 58:6 58:11 58:12 58:13

The Daily Revelation Edition 58

Analysis

TWO PARTIES, ONE VERDICT: How Al-Mujadila's Final Verses Sort All of Humanity Into God's Camp or Satan's

The final third of Al-Mujadila constructs one of the starkest binary divisions in the entire Quran. After twenty-one verses of graduated legislation, psychological analysis, and social instruction, the surah arrives at a verdict that admits no middle ground: every human being belongs to one of two parties. God's or Satan's. There is no third option, no neutral zone, no undecided category.

The descent toward this final sorting begins with the hypocrites -- those who "befriended a people with whom God has become angry". The Quran's diagnosis of these figures is not political but existential: "Have you considered those who befriended a people with whom God has become angry? They are not of you, nor of them. And they swear to a lie while they know" 58:14. This is the most damning psychological portrait in the surah. They are not confused. They are not misinformed. They know they are lying. Their duplicity is deliberate, their loyalty is performed, and their oaths are instruments of deception: "They took their oaths as a screen, and prevented others from God's path. They will have a shameful punishment" 58:16.

The Quran then strips them of the two things they believe will save them: wealth and progeny. "Neither their possessions nor their children will avail them anything against God. These are the inhabitants of the Fire, dwelling therein forever" 58:17. This is not merely an eschatological statement. It is a demolition of the entire power structure of seventh-century Arabian society, where a man's worth was measured by his camels and his sons. The Quran says: none of it counts. Not a single dirham, not a single heir, will stand between you and divine accountability.

The portrait reaches its most psychologically devastating moment in verse eighteen: "On the Day when God will resurrect them altogether--they will swear to Him, as they swear to you, thinking that they are upon something. Indeed, they themselves are the liars" 58:18. The image is staggering. These are people so habituated to lying that they will attempt to deceive God Himself on the Day of Judgment. They will stand before the Creator of the universe and deploy the same tactics they used in Medinan council meetings -- the same oaths, the same false sincerity, the same performance of piety. And the Quran names the pathology: they think they are standing on something. They think their performance is working. They are, in the Quran's final assessment, not merely dishonest but delusional.

The diagnosis leads to the naming: "Satan has taken hold of them, and so has caused them to forget the remembrance of God. These are the partisans of Satan. Indeed, it is Satan's partisans who are the losers" 58:19. Party of Satan. Hizb al-Shaytan. The label is permanent. And opposed to them, a divine declaration of inevitable victory: "God has written: 'I will certainly prevail, I and My messengers.' God is Strong and Mighty" 58:21. The outcome is not in doubt. It was never in doubt. God has already written the result.

And then the surah's final verse -- its culmination, its closing argument, and one of the most powerful passages in the Quran: "You will not find a people who believe in God and the Last Day, loving those who oppose God and His Messenger, even if they were their parents, or their children, or their siblings, or their close relatives. These--He has inscribed faith in their hearts, and has supported them with a spirit from Him. And He will admit them into Gardens beneath which rivers flow, wherein they will dwell forever. God is pleased with them, and they are pleased with Him. These are the partisans of God. Indeed, it is God's partisans who are the successful" 58:22.

Two parties. Two allegiances. Two outcomes. The surah that began with one woman's domestic grievance ends with the entire human species sorted into two camps. And the sorting criterion is not what you believe but whom you love -- even when that love costs you your closest blood. The Party of God is not defined by theological sophistication or ritual perfection. It is defined by a love so fierce that it will not compromise with those who oppose its Object, even when those opponents share your DNA. And God's verdict on His own party is the most beautiful phrase in the surah, perhaps in the entire Quran: "God is pleased with them, and they are pleased with Him." Mutual satisfaction between Creator and creation. The relationship fulfilled on both sides.

58:14 58:15 58:16 58:17 58:18 58:19 58:20 58:21 58:22

The Daily Revelation Edition 58

Psychology

THE FIVE STAGES OF MORAL COLLAPSE: How Al-Mujadila Maps the Hypocrite's Mind From Whisper to Delusion

Al-Mujadila contains one of the most detailed psychological profiles of the hypocrite in the entire Quran -- not as a theological category but as a clinical portrait. If we trace the surah's description of the munafiq from verses eight through nineteen, we find a progression that modern psychology would recognise as the anatomy of moral collapse.

Stage One: Compulsive Behaviour. The hypocrites were told not to conspire secretly, yet they could not stop: "Have you noted those who were prohibited from conspiring secretly, but then reverted to what they were prohibited from?" 58:8. This is not mere disobedience. It is relapse. The Arabic 'adu (they returned) carries the weight of habitual regression -- a person who knows the prohibition, acknowledges it, and then walks back into the behaviour as if the prohibition never existed. In addiction literature, this is called lapse-relapse cycling. The hypocrites are not choosing evil in a single dramatic moment. They are drifting back into it, again and again, pulled by the gravity of habit.

Stage Two: Performative Piety. When these conspirators approach the Prophet, they do not come with hostility. They come with a greeting -- but a distorted one: "And when they come to you, they greet you with a greeting that God never greeted you with" 58:8. The scholars explain that certain opponents would twist the Arabic salutation, turning as-salamu alaykum (peace be upon you) into as-samu alaykum (death be upon you). The difference is a single letter. The deception is deliberate. This is the psychology of passive aggression elevated to a spiritual art form -- hostility encoded within the vocabulary of respect.

Stage Three: Self-Deception. The conspirators begin to believe their own performance: "And they say within themselves, 'Why does God not punish us for what we say?'" 58:8. This is the most dangerous stage. They have moved from knowing they are lying to wondering whether they are lying at all. If God is not punishing them, perhaps their position is legitimate. Perhaps their whispered insults are permissible. Perhaps the absence of immediate consequence is the same as divine approval. The Quran's response is devastating in its economy: "Hell is enough for them. They will roast in it. What a miserable destiny!" 58:8. The punishment is not absent. It is deferred. And the deferral is not mercy. It is rope.

Stage Four: Identity Capture. By verse nineteen, the hypocrites have crossed a threshold from which there is no return. They are no longer people who sometimes conspire. They are the Party of Satan: "Satan has taken hold of them, and so has caused them to forget the remembrance of God. These are the partisans of Satan" 58:19. The Arabic istahwadha -- 'has taken hold' -- implies total domination. Satan has not whispered a suggestion. He has seized control. And the mechanism of his control is not temptation but amnesia: he makes them forget God. The remembrance of God -- dhikr Allah -- is the immune system of the believing heart. When it is disabled, there is no firewall left. Every subsequent thought, every subsequent decision, occurs in a God-vacuum. The verse's verdict is absolute: "Indeed, it is Satan's partisans who are the losers" 58:19.

Stage Five: Terminal Delusion. On the Day of Judgment itself, these people will attempt to lie to God: "On the Day when God will resurrect them altogether--they will swear to Him, as they swear to you, thinking that they are upon something. Indeed, they themselves are the liars" 58:18. The pathology has become so total that it survives death. They have lied so long, to so many, that they can no longer distinguish between performance and reality. They will stand before Omniscience and attempt to bluff. The Quran does not describe this with anger. It describes it with something closer to clinical pity: "Indeed, they themselves are the liars." Not 'they are liars.' They themselves are the liars -- the definitive article marking them as the category itself, the prototype, the purest specimen of untruth the universe has produced.

The progression -- from compulsive relapse, to performative piety, to self-deception, to identity capture, to terminal delusion -- is not merely a theological taxonomy. It is a diagnostic manual. Al-Mujadila is telling every reader: this is how moral collapse works. Not in a single catastrophic moment, but in five quiet stages, each one slightly harder to detect than the last. By the time you reach stage five, you do not even know you have been captured. You think you are standing on something. You are standing on nothing.

58:8 58:18 58:19

The Daily Revelation Editorial Edition 58

✸ ✸ ✸

Letter from the Editor: The Woman Who Was Louder Than Silence

We live in an age that celebrates the whistleblower, the protester, the person who speaks truth to power. We build monuments to civil disobedience. We teach our children that injustice unchallenged is injustice endorsed. And we sometimes forget that the template for all of this -- the original act of a powerless individual refusing to accept an unjust verdict -- is not a modern invention.

Khawlah bint Tha'labah had no platform. No social media following. No legal representation. No political constituency. She had a husband who had declared her 'like his mother's back' -- a sentence that, in her world, carried the force of law. She was not divorced, so she could not leave. She was not a wife, so she could not live. She was trapped in a grammatical prison built from a single metaphor.

And she did the only thing available to her: she went to the Prophet and argued. She complained. She refused to accept silence as an answer. And when the Prophet could not give her an immediate ruling, she did something even more extraordinary -- she appealed over his head. She complained to God.

Aisha, who was present, reported that she could barely hear the woman's words. Khawlah's voice was not loud. Her argument was not polished. But it reached further than any voice in the history of rhetoric has ever reached -- it reached the Throne of God. And God answered with revelation.

This is the surah's first and most radical lesson: God hears the quiet ones. The opening verse does not say 'God heard the one who shouted.' It says God heard the one who argued, the one who complained. The verbs are intimate, domestic, personal. This is not a battlefield prayer. It is a kitchen-table grievance. And it changed the law.

The rest of the surah expands this principle outward. If God hears the whispered complaint of one woman, He also hears the whispered conspiracies of every hypocrite: "There is no secret counsel between three, but He is their fourth" 58:7. The same hearing that rescued Khawlah condemns the conspirators. The same God who made room for her argument will make room for those who make room for others: "When you are told to make room in your gatherings, make room; God will make room for you" 58:11. And the same God who took the side of one wronged wife will sort all of humanity into two camps -- His and Satan's -- based not on what they said in public but on what they whispered in private.

Al-Mujadila begins with a woman who would not be silent and ends with a God who has always been listening. Between those two facts, every conspiracy dissolves, every false oath collapses, and every secret meeting is revealed to have had one more attendee than anyone counted.

For Reflection
Think of a time when you dismissed someone's complaint because they were powerless -- because they lacked status, eloquence, or influence. Now consider that Khawlah bint Tha'labah's barely audible protest reached the Throne of God and changed Islamic law forever. Whose complaint are you currently ignoring? What if God is already listening to them?
Supplication
O Allah, You heard the woman who argued when no one else would listen. Hear me now. Hear the complaints I have swallowed, the injustices I have accepted in silence, the words I was too afraid to say. And hear also the complaints others bring to me -- make me a listener worthy of the trust they place in my ears. You are the Hearing, the Seeing, the One from whom no whisper is lost. Let me never be the reason someone's voice goes unheard. Ameen.
✸ ✸ ✸

The Daily Revelation Back Page Edition 58

Today's Action
Today, find one person in your life whose complaint you have been ignoring or minimizing -- a spouse, a child, a colleague, a friend. Sit with them. Listen. Not to fix, not to judge, not to respond. Just to hear. Then remember: God heard Khawlah before the Prophet could answer her. The least you can do is hear the person in front of you.
Weekly Challenge
The Listening Audit: For seven days, keep a private journal. Each evening, write down every complaint or grievance someone brought to you that day. Note whether you listened fully, dismissed it, or deferred it. By the end of the week, identify your pattern. Are you a listener or a deflector? Then choose one unresolved complaint from the week and take one concrete step to address it -- not because you have to, but because God heard Khawlah, and the standard has been set.
Related Editions
Edition 2 Contains the foundational divorce legislation (2:226-232) that Al-Mujadila refines -- the broader framework within which zihar is abolished
Edition 33 Addresses the Prophet's household directly and contains further marriage legislation, including the prohibition of treating adopted sons' former wives as forbidden (33:37)
Edition 4 The Women -- the Quran's most extensive treatment of women's rights in marriage, divorce, inheritance, and family law
Edition 49 The Chambers -- addresses community etiquette, the prohibition of spying and backbiting, and the equality of all people before God
Edition 63 The Hypocrites -- the surah explicitly named for the group whose psychology Al-Mujadila dissects in verses 8-19
Characters in This Edition
Allah Khawlah bint Tha'labah Muhammad Iblis Hypocrites Believers Disbelievers
Coming Next
NEXT EDITION: Surah Al-Hashr -- The Gathering. When the Jewish tribe of Banu Nadir is expelled from Medina, the Quran reflects on the psychology of those who thought their fortresses would protect them from God. Plus: the most concentrated collection of God's Beautiful Names in the entire Quran -- the final three verses that became one of Islam's most beloved prayers.
Page 1 of 8
Ed. 57 Ed. 59